Health and care complaints system is 'utterly bewildering' for people
The concerns of users and worried family members looking to complain about the service they have received from their local hospital, GP or care home, are going unheard because the current system is simply too complex.
Healthwatch England's work to map the complaints landscape has shown a staggering 75 types of organisations in England have a role in complaints handling and support, from councils and CCGs locally to national regulators. See BBC and HSJ (subscription required) coverage of this story.
Research conducted in October last year showed that one in three people report having experienced or knowing someone who has experienced poor care. Yet a YouGov survey we commissioned of 2076 UK adults showed that less than half of those who had a bad experience between 2010 and 2013 actually did anything to report it. The results showed that two in five (43 per cent) said this was because they didn't know how to complain or provide feedback and half (49 per cent) said it was because they lacked confidence that their complaint would be dealt with effectively or thought that it wouldn't make any real difference.
Of those who did pursue their complaint over one in ten (13 per cent) entered a formal complaints process. This means the system is failing to take any formal learning from almost nine out ten experiences of poor care.
The failure of the complaints system is being compounded by the lack of consistent and easy to access complaints support services. Whilst NHS advocacy is fragmented, with the level of service varying across the country, advocacy for complaints in care is almost non-existent.
If the health and care system is to learn from its mistakes, then the complaints system needs to be simplified. It also needs to be more joined up to ensure there is ‘no wrong door’ for those looking to raise a complaint, and the right information and support needs to be made available for those who want to complain.
Anna Bradley, Chair of Healthwatch England, said: “It’s no wonder the public are left confused and frustrated. With so many organisations involved it’s difficult to know where to start, let alone having the strength and persistence to navigate the system on your own. A key improvement would be a straightforward and independent advocacy service to provide the support people need to make their voices heard.
“There will need to be very significant change in the complaints system if it is to benefit from the intelligence and insight that complaints can offer and use it to drive real improvement for the people actually using services.”
Julie Mellor, Parliamentary and Health Service Ombudsman said: “We agree with Healthwatch that the current complaints system is too complex and we are working with the Department of Health, NHS England and regulators to help people better understand where they need to go when they want to raise a concern.
“We are working with Healthwatch England and the Local Government Ombudsman to help people create a vision of what the public can expect from the complaints system that would transform their experiences of raising concerns. But we need significant change in the way complaints are handled across public services and that’s why we are calling for a single Public Ombudsman Service to be responsible for all complaints concerning public services, including health and social care in England."
About Healthwatch England's role in improving the complaints system
Healthwatch England is the independent consumer champion for health and social care in England. We have independent statutory powers, as stated in the Health and Social Care Act 2012, to ensure the consumers’ voice is heard and best practice is delivered in health and social care nationally. We are also focused on providing leadership, guidance and support to the development of the network of local Healthwatch that launched in April 2013.
We are on the cross-agency Complaints Programme Board, co-ordinated by the Department of Health, which has a single and agreed work programme to ensure alignment on the improvement and reform of complaint systems. The Board shares a joint ambition to ensure complaints are handled effectively, with learning from them shared and acted upon locally and nationally for the benefit of the public, families and carers. We are working as part of this Board to ensure that the needs, experiences and ideas of consumers are at the heart of improvement and reform in health and social care complaints handling and advocacy.